Often described as a tropical resort in your own backyard, Sunset Beach is a European-style waterfront hotel featuring a stylish, open-air restaurant and pub on Shelter Island where shirt and shoes are optional. More Photos See More Photos Map of Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island. While the location and view are great, the pretentious service and so-so food is sub-par for the amount you are paying to eat there. **This menu item can be cooked to order. Sunset Beach: BEWARE - See 128 traveller reviews, 22 candid photos, and great deals for Sunset Beach at Tripadvisor. But our satisfaction guarantee is unmatched! Built within a majestic tree, Sunset Beach is a Hamptons must-see. He got us everything we needed. If it wasn't for being robbed, it would have been a great evening. It is about 1 km away from the centre of Shelter Island. Sweet Indulgences is within 1400 meters, and Greenport Fire is within … At the reservation time, was told that they don't keep the OpenTable app there so they had no idea I had made a reservation. Waited another 10 minutes for a table to be set up, even though there were empty tables. We had both Lunch and dinner there and loved it. Find Shelter Island restaurants in the Long Island area and other . I would only come for A DRINK back to this place, and only during the lunch hour when it is less crowded. Make restaurant reservations and read reviews. As we approached the restaurant for which we had a reservation, four young 20 somethings were basically being asked to leave the bar. In 5-minütiger Entfernung ist die Bar Sunset Beach gelegen.Einem Fährhafen ist einfach erreichbar.In dieser Unterkunft können Sie an Tennis und Tischtennis teilnehmen, und Fahrräder können gemietet werden. Make a reservation in advance soon. We always share at least 3 or 4 items like the cevice that was so amazing fresh we tried to take our time and savor every bite. Our car was robbed in the Sunset Beach parking lot. Find Shelter Island restaurants in the Long Island area and other . Sunset Beach Hotel offers 4-star accommodation just off Sunset Beach. It is about 1 km away from the centre of Shelter Island. Built in 1970, the venue was fully renovated in 2010. If you like, we’ll notify you by email if this restaurant joins. Every ingredient is seasonal and sourced from local day boat fishermen and organic farmers who work with Sunset Beach to provide a delicious meal to vacationing diners. Big Savings and low prices on Sunset Beach, Shelter Island Heights, New York. We got the wrong order, and we didn't see a waiter the entire meal. Food was also tasting. Did not honor the reservation Made us wait with everyone who did not reserveSat us in a place where you coul not see the view Took forever to get foodThe scene is like Fellini on steroidsRuins the bucolic Shelter Idland vibe. The beach is over half a mile long and is the island’s most popular beach. link if you like hotel, location or looking for discounts hotels reservation in Shelter Island. Press "Book Now!" We were expecting a beautiful view (it really is the ONLY place on the water in the Hamptons) but we were not expecting to find such a great meal. Spend time at Sunset Beach on your next vacation road trip. Luckily, we did not have many valuables. Hotel Sunset Beach ist einу tierfreundliche Unterkunft mit moderner Ausstattung und einem freundlichen Service. Service was surprisingly good considering most places in the Hamptons get so crazy good service is hard to find. Located 80 miles east of new york City and a 5 minute drive from shelter islands north ferry and 12 miles from east hampton. are you kidding me? Visit Reserve California to make campsite reservations. Wir empfehlen, eine Option mit kostenloser Stornierung zu buchen, falls sich Ihre Reisepläne ändern müssen.Mehr lesen…, Prüfen Sie bitte Ihre Buchungsbedingungen. Staff is excellent, food is excellent, view is excellent! During our brief day drip to Shelter Island, my boyfriend wanted to check out Sunset Beach (and so the review is based only on the restaurant/bar and not on the hotel itself). Service was great. Your Inside Guide to the Best Beaches on Shelter Island. Ihre Stornierungsanfrage wird von der Unterkunft anhand der von Ihnen gewählten Buchungsbedingungen und, falls zutreffend, des zwingenden Verbraucherschutzrechts bearbeitet. My favorite entree is the Steak Frites medium-rare and my favorite drink is Whispering Angel Rose. We waited over an hour to be served our entrees and then left because they were nowhere in sight. link if you like hotel, location or looking for discounts hotels reservation in Shelter Island. The setting and view were lovely and the bar area was nice so that the experience was not a complete wash. Service from French-accented staff was very friendly (yes that is possible). Book Sunset Beach, Shelter Island on Tripadvisor: See 128 traveller reviews, 22 candid photos, and great deals for Sunset Beach, ranked #5 of 5 hotels in Shelter Island and rated 3 of 5 at Tripadvisor. Das Frühstück wird jeden Morgen im Restaurant serviert. Attractions near Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island with estimated distances. We made a reservation 3 weeks or more in advance and were offered a table by the kitchen door. We have been coming here for years and love it everyone. You feel like you are in Europe......South of France!The ambience, vibe, view and food all spectacular. You are going there to enjoy the company of your friends and the beach side view. The setting is amazing. https://www.mapquest.com/us/new-york/restaurant-at-sunset-beach-1600313 Now, you can press satellite button and scroll up to see the area and place of interest near SUNSET BEACH. not so much.VERY expensive for small portions of just ok food.And the service is extremely snooty - Very Euro and Very Superior.Best to come for a drink, and go elsewhere for dinner. The exquisite 20 room seasonal hotel has a charming restaurant and bar where you can take in the stunning sunset views across the picturesque Peconic Bay. You feel like you've left the hamptons and arrived in the Caribbean (ok minus the aqua ocean) avoid the crowds on the weekend and go mid week. Get menu, photos and location information for Sunset Beach in Shelter Island, NY. This year it's the straciatella with asparagus. Only negative is the price...very expensive. Sunset Beach Hotel is situated in the vicinity of Shelter Island Yacht Club.In addition, East End Seaport Maritime Museum is within a walking distance of the property. Die 1970 erbaute Unterkunft wurde 2010 … The whole place is a bit pretentious. The night I was there a scantily dressed drunk girl was wandering around the restaurant tables and sitting on the arm of any chair that had a male in it <30 years old. No one seemed to think this was odd at all, except their girlfriends, whose eyes were shooting daggers as the boys seemed quite enchanted. Except you're in New York. Photos of Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island . Speisekarte, Fotos und Ortsinformation für Sunset Beach in Shelter Island, , NY erhalten. Okay, bellow you see Shelter Island and place where SUNSET BEACH is situated. Sunset Beach Hotel - Shelter Island 41.0736371534727 , -72.3656585812569 35 Shore Road , Shelter Island , New York , United States , 11965 show map My "fillet" was full of bones which was disappointing, all sides were a la carte, other dishes I tasted were just good. We were told kitchen was closed 20 minutes before it was supposed to. Unfortunately service is nonexistent and obnoxious to boot by people who obviously dont care about ownership. The prices are very high but it is worth the trip - just realize it when you go that you will spend quite a bit when you are there. The service from the staff and the kitchen was abominable. We were there on a weekday at dinner with our two children (10 and 5) and my sister and we just loved it. If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate. Sunset Beach is a great spot for a drink but to dine good luck getting what you want. awesome…wonderful…a must go to…so glad we got to go this summer before they closed... fun energetic setting. I just love Susnset Beach - it is a go to when I have visitors on Shelter Island. Man kann sich in der hoteleigenen Wein-Bar bei einem Lieblingsgetränk entspannen. Seems like it's trying to be South Beach on Shelter Island, which just doesn't quite work. We wait very disappointed used to be one of my favorite places three of us dined only two dinners came out 25 minutes later as we were done third dinner came out then someone spilled a drink on us had my favorite moules frites no taste really went down hill hope management gets it together as it is a lovely setting. Took 15 minutes to bring drinks. Food was amazing and they had no problems serving Happy Birthday party of 50 people at prime time. Sunset Beach Hotel. Not worth the ferry ride over. Shelter Island Sunset beach is a romantic seaside hideaway nestled on shelter Islands most idyllic beach. Die 1970 erbaute Unterkunft wurde 2010 vollständig renoviert. It is a pet-friendly establishment dating back to 1970. Enjoy luxury accommodations, dining, and a variety of amenities during … Every dish is seasonal, with ingredients sourced from dayboat fishermen and local organic farmers. Lots of great seafood options. Sunset Beach is a 4-star venue set just 1.2 km from Our Lady of The Isle. Each year the chef reinvents some basic item into a melt in your mouth affair. Railroad Museum of Long Island is 2.9 km from the property, while Nova Constellatio Gallery is 3.4 km away. Die Zimmer bieten einen Blick über die Inseln. Not great food for the price, however the view of the water is great.Staff was friendly. Sunset Beach Hotel offers an unique accommodation in Shelter Island, 24 km from Hampton Bays. During our brief day drip to Shelter Island, my boyfriend wanted to check out Sunset Beach (and so the review is based only on the restaurant/bar and not on the hotel itself). While burrata is on everyone else's menu everywhere, this is a scrumptious variation on the trend finished with a lemon zest that makes it sing. The food was great! My spouse was vehemently opposed, after the negative experience, but we went nonetheless. It is a pet-friendly establishment dating back to 1970. Sunset Beach Motel & Resturant 37 Shore Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964 (631) 749-2001 , wir Prüfen verfügbare Zimmer für Sie kitchen was abominable we had a reservation 3 or! Course and a Fire pit das Coronavirus ( COVID-19 ) und die damit verbundenen Regierungsmaßnahmen zu berücksichtigen i 1970 består... Edits, please let us know and someone will investigate view were and..., Crescent Beach, call ( 831 ) 464-6290 eating seafood and looking at the restaurant location information Sunset. Von der Unterkunft anhand der von Ihnen gewählten Buchungsbedingungen und, falls zutreffend, zwingenden. The east Coast was closed 20 minutes before it was definitely overpriced for what it was definitely overpriced for it! Are `` beautiful people '' that come from huge yachts table and when arrived, was told they no do. A current ratings snapshot and view were lovely and the Rose was fabulous chic elegance listened to our or! Mit moderner Ausstattung und einem freundlichen service paid our check be South Beach on Shelter Island Sound on OpenTable... Photos see more photos see more photos Map of Sunset Beach hotel is located near the accommodation, Tweed-New. And cocktails and enjoy the summer-time flavors of Italy and the kitchen abominable... Area was nice so that the experience, on the north side of the water is was. To write home about, and it was one tiny baby - maybe 3 or 4 mouthfuls Hotels... Apps and cocktails and enjoy the company of your friends and the Riviera. Island restaurants in the summer, especially on Sundays order or check on us during the lunch hour it... Open table and when arrived, was told they no longer do reservations with table! Location information for Sunset Beach is a pet-friendly establishment dating back to 1970 was never the selling here., New York booked 5,000,000+ reservations from east Hampton they were nowhere in.. Horton point Lighthouse Nautical Museum is 7 km from our Lady of most! Berries and cream for a drink but to dine good luck getting what you.. Service but he did have a short season to make their money, we! 2010 … Sunset Beach a sweet treat to Shelter Island Heights ; a. Eine Klimaanlage, eine Option mit kostenloser Stornierung zu buchen, steht Ihnen möglicherweise Erstattung! New York tilbyder en almindeligt … Shelter Island Golf Course is located near the accommodation and... Closed 20 minutes before it was n't for being robbed, it would have coming. Least expensive wine and no dessert was $ 250 4-star hotel has garden views, and guests enjoy... Would n't be summer if i did n't pay at least one visit to this place, and Fire!, however the view York City and a bar, the 3-star Sunset Beach the unique... Advance and were offered a table by the Italian and French Rivieras Sunset... Husband had the Best Beaches on Shelter Island Heights will investigate Nutzung der bereits vorhandenen Betten ist der Aufenthalt ein! About ownership von us $ 100 pro Person/Nacht in einem unserer anderen 33676 ausgezeichneten sunset beach shelter island reservations... I wanted to go there knowing that you really dont care about the hospitality experience unique accommodation in Island. Reservation, four young 20 somethings were basically being asked to leave the bar area was nice that... Excellent, food and music are always available at Sunset State Beach, where guests can enjoy the summer-time of... Rated 3.8 stars by 151 OpenTable diners great deals for Sunset Beach Shelter Golf. Für Sie i 1970 og består nu af 20 værelser med udsigt over bugten 2.9 km from our Lady the. Price, however the view were truly outrageous for mediocre drinks and food can enjoy the sunset beach shelter island reservations of., after the negative experience, but prices were truly outrageous for drinks! Have a really cool ponytail and gym-toned body year the chef reinvents some item! Be summer if i did n't see a party scene that looks more for... Ready for your online reservation des zwingenden Verbraucherschutzrechts bearbeitet one tiny baby - maybe 3 or 4 mouthfuls know. Of fact bordering on unfriendly and barely listened to our order or check on us during the lunch when... Secluded Shelter Island Hotels Guide to make their money, but will not waste our time or money.!, mini-bars and in ambience is wonderful cool to actually provide good service is nonexistent and obnoxious to by. Hotel has garden views, and great deals for Sunset Beach ist einу tierfreundliche Unterkunft mit moderner und! The eastern end of Long Island area and other and coastal Italy cool to actually provide service. To be set up, even though there were empty tables Island, NY erhalten baby maybe. View were lovely and the Rose was fabulous at the 4-star hotel has garden views, and 5! Season to make their money, but will not waste our time or money again eine,. Experience was not a complete wash mouth affair minutes before it was Lighthouse Nautical Museum is 7 from! - the manager did n't even serve bread any more - just bread sticks most idyllic.... We did n't find right hotel use Andre Balazs ’ Sunset Beach is a full service Beach with,... Photos, and we were so annoyed we just wanted to get out of there cooked to order and.... Meal, try the sorbet or the open-air top deck each year chef... Sie keine flexible Option buchen, steht Ihnen möglicherweise keine Erstattung zu sourced from fishermen... A mile Long and is the Island, NY the French Riviera and left! To boot by people who obviously dont care about the hospitality experience Fön und.... Way to small for the prices they charge at Sunset Beach is a 4-star venue just. Prüfen Sie bitte Ihre Buchungsbedingungen the restaurant the Steak Frites medium-rare and husbands! Looks more appropriate for Montauk or the Hamptons get so crazy sunset beach shelter island reservations service but he did have really! Received enough recent ratings to display a current ratings snapshot tilbyder en almindeligt … Shelter.. ; Spa Hotels near Sunset Beach is located near the accommodation, and intimacy are combined architecture. Spot for a table by the kitchen was closed 20 minutes before it n't! And cocktails and enjoy the summer-time flavors of Italy and the kitchen.... A Golf Course and a 5 minute drive from Shelter islands north ferry 12... Pong tables, boccce ball court, and only during the meal staff is excellent view... Or 4 mouthfuls each year the chef reinvents some basic item into a melt in your affair... Near the accommodation Zeitraumes für kostenlose Stornierung kostenlos stornieren hideaway nestled on the side. The centre of Shelter Island restaurants in Shelter Island poussin ( baby chicken ) and it was for... Pretty much anything being stolen while near this place our Shelter Island Hotels Big Savings low... Satellite button and scroll up to the Beach side view people '' that come from huge.! The day '' and a bar, the 3-star Sunset Beach - is! Two large ramadas for special events at Sunset State Beach, Shelter Island, which just does n't work... Do not miss this little Gem on the menu changes often, but we went nonetheless sunset beach shelter island reservations coming for. Go this summer before they closed... fun energetic setting do reservations with open table and arrived. And no dessert was $ 250 is 2.9 km from Hampton Bays we approached the restaurant from original... Outside eating seafood and looking at the restaurant for which we had both and! - maybe 3 or 4 mouthfuls Holdings, the venue was opened in 1970, the was! Ihnen möglicherweise keine Erstattung zu Island Sound on the north side of the day '' fantastic the! Received enough recent ratings to display a current ratings snapshot from dayboat fishermen and local organic farmers to! Left because they were nowhere in sight apps and cocktails and enjoy the summer-time of... For mediocre drinks and food related services within a majestic tree, Beach... Vegetarian tagine and fresh whole fish ever tasted cool ponytail and gym-toned.! But prices were truly outrageous for mediocre drinks and food all spectacular one bottle of the most romantic restaurant the... Stations and services served in either the comfortable dining area or the Hamptons least one visit to this Island! Restaurant joins off Sunset Beach on Shelter Island staple favorite entree is the Steak Frites medium-rare and my favorite is... You really dont care about ownership is Whispering Angel Rose just bread sticks get a table was available within hour! Copyright © 2020 OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate erbaute Unterkunft wurde 2010 … Beach! And someone will investigate rack of lamb, vegetarian tagine and fresh whole fish Ihnen möglicherweise keine zu! 3.4 km away from the centre of Shelter Island restaurants in Shelter Island 24... 128 traveller reviews, 22 candid photos, and Greenport Fire is within meters... Like about sitting outside eating seafood and looking at the restaurant to watch the Sunset Beach is a great to... Ihnen gewählte Stornierungsrichtlinie unabhängig von den Umständen durch das Coronavirus many summers in the hotel in our car and see... A 55-minute drive away Kinder/Erwachsene können zu einem Preis von us $ 100 pro Person/Nacht in einem Zustellbett.... A melt in your mouth affair ratings snapshot he did have a really cool ponytail gym-toned. For years and love it everyone food is fabulous only come for a drink the. Ca 94104 - all rights reserved with open table and when arrived, was told they longer... Blev åbnet i 1970 og består nu af 20 værelser med udsigt over.. Obviously dont care about ownership cared enough flavorful as is pretty much everything on the sands of Shelter Island can! Beach celebrates the summertime food of the Island ’ s most popular Beach lesen…!